您現在的位置: > Language Tips > Audio & Video > Normal Speed News  
 





 
Ruling puts Guantanamo trials in doubt
[ 2007-06-05 09:01 ]

A U.S. military judge has dismissed charges against a detainee at the Guantanamo detention center, based on a technical issue that could affect all the current and potential charges against detainees. The Defense Department says the prosecutor will appeal the ruling. VOA's Al Pessin reports from the Pentagon.

The military judge, U.S. Army Colonel Peter Brownback, ruled Monday during a hearing at Guantanamo that charges against Canadian Omar Khadr are invalid. Khadr is charged with murder and other crimes related to the death of a U.S. soldier in Afghanistan in 2002.

Pentagon spokesman Commander J.D. Gordon told VOA the judge decided Khadr cannot be tried because an earlier process did not designate him an "unlawful enemy combatant," as a new law requires. Gordon says Khadr and the other detainees at Guantanamo were only designated "enemy combatants," without the word "unlawful."

"For all intents and purposes it's the same thing," said Commander Gordon. "It's just an issue of semantics. We've already said they were unlawful in 2004-2005 as well because of a variety of factors. They don't wear a uniform. They're not members of [the] armed forces of another nation-state. They don't display arms openly. They don't have a chain of command. All those issues make them unlawful enemy combatants. So they were already 'unlawful enemy combatants' back when they were designated as such, however the technical verbiage was just 'enemy combatant.'"

But the director of Terrorism and Counter-terrorism at Human Rights Watch in New York, Joanne Mariner, says that technicality has some important substance behind it.

"There is a question about whether some people held at Guantanamo are in fact lawful combatants, members of the Taleban who were the armed forces of Afghanistan during the conflict with the United States, so, in fact, under international law, were considered soldiers and had the right to fight," said Joanne Mariner. "This is something that the United States has always dismissed. The court is correct to say there is a meaningful distinction between lawful and unlawful enemy combatants."

Judge Brownback at Guantanamo said Khadr could be re-charged if he undergoes a new hearing to determine his status, and if that process officially designates him an "unlawful enemy combatant." That is the phrase used in the law passed last year by Congress to establish what is called the Military Commissions process for trying Guantanamo detainees.

News reports from Guantanamo quote the chief defense attorney for the detainees, who is also a U.S. military officer, as saying the judge's ruling applies to all the detainees and is further evidence that the process is, in his words, "a failure" and should be stopped.

But the Pentagon spokesman, Commander Gordon, says the military prosecutor will appeal Monday's ruling to a review panel in Washington set up to supervise the detainee tribunals. Commander Gordon says it will be the first time the panel has been activated.

Joanne Mariner at Human Rights Watch says the military judge did the right thing in this ruling, but she is still not convinced the Military Commissions process is fair, or that this ruling will have a significant, long-term impact.

"It is showing that they are trying to follow the procedures as they exist," she said. "But I wouldn't go so far as to say this reflects a substantive independence. I think this is probably something that the military is going to remedy fairly easily."

Mariner says if the judge's ruling is upheld on appeal, a new status hearing could be held for Omar Khadr fairly soon, with others to follow in the coming months.

Khadr is a Canadian citizen. His case is particularly controversial because he was just 15 years old at the time he allegedly threw a hand grenade during a battle in Afghanistan that killed an American soldier. He has been in U.S. custody for five years.

In March, Australian David Hicks became the first detainee processed through the new tribunals. After a pre-trial agreement, he was convicted of one charge of providing material support to terrorism and is serving his nine-month sentence back in Australia. He had a different military judge, who did not address the difference in terminology between the old process and the new one.

Hicks and Khadr are two of only three detainees who have been formally charged under the new system. There are about 380 detainees at Guantanamo, but some have been approved for release without trial, and others may be released this year through a separate annual review process.


點擊進入更多VOA常速

(來源:VOA  英語點津姍姍編輯

 
 
相關文章 Related Stories
 
         
 
 
 
 
 
         

 

 

 
 

48小時內最熱門

     

本頻道最新推薦

     
  Newsmaker:Zoellick, nominee to lead World Bank
  US authorities foil terror plot at JFK airport
  《陽光小美女》(精講之六)
  Bush unveils climate change proposal
  A brief history of the WTO

論壇熱貼

     
  翻譯:注水肉 (中國特色,有難度)
  DJ 全稱是什么
  "攀比"怎么說
  求助!“購物返券”如何翻譯?
  “使用須知”怎么準確翻譯啊
  “無名窩點”怎么譯?






主站蜘蛛池模板: 4虎永免费最新永久免费地址| 国产精品美女久久久久| 国产精品毛片va一区二区三区| 国产国产人免费人成免费视频| 免费看美女吃男生私人部位| 亚洲午夜无码久久久久小说 | 久久精品国产99国产精品亚洲 | 日本免费成人网| 大ji巴c死你h| 国产免费久久精品丫丫| 亚洲精品无码久久久久秋霞| 久久久久久久女国产乱让韩| 91色视频在线| 美女露100%胸无遮挡免费观看| 欧美人与性动交另类| 好吊色青青青国产综合在线观看| 国产剧果冻传媒星空在线| 亚洲图片小说网| 一个看片免费视频www| 韩国一级毛片完整高清| 欧美成人精品三级网站| 女人张腿给男人桶视频免费版| 国产午夜精品理论片| 亚洲小说区图片区另类春色| www成人在线观看| 色吊丝永久性观看网站| 桃子视频在线观看高清免费视频| 在线观看av片| 免费网站看v片在线香蕉| 中文字幕在线视频第一页| 黄网免费在线观看| 欧美xxxx做受性欧美88| 在线a免费观看最新网站| 八戒网站免费观看视频| 久久久久无码国产精品不卡 | 国产精品一国产精品| 亚洲综合在线一区二区三区| 一区二区三区无码高清视频| 老公和他朋友一块上我可以吗| 日本红怡院在线| 国产在AJ精品|