The fate of horses at risk

Updated: 2013-09-01 08:10

By Fernanda Santos(The New York Times)

  Print Mail Large Medium  Small

 The fate of horses at risk

Free-roaming horses cost the Navajos $200,000 a year in damage to property and range. The horses are in competition for water and forage. Photographs by Diego James Robles for The New York Times

The fate of horses at risk

Issue pits Indians vs. stars

It seemed like a logical alliance for the interconnected worlds of Hollywood and politics. Bill Richardson, a former governor of New Mexico, and the movie star Robert Redford joined animal rights groups in a lawsuit to block the revival of horse slaughter in the United States, proclaiming they were "standing with Native American leaders," to whom horse slaughter "constitutes a violation of tribal cultural values."

Soon, though, the two men found themselves on a collision course with the Navajo Nation, America's largest federally recognized tribe, whose president released a recent letter to Congress asserting his support for horse slaughtering.

Free-roaming horses cost the Navajos $200,000 a year in damage to property and range, said Ben Shelly, the Navajo president. There is a gap between reality and romance when, he said, "outsiders" like Mr. Redford - who counts gunslinger, sheriff's deputy and horse whisperer among his movie roles - interpret the struggles of the Indians.

"Maybe Robert Redford can come and see what he can do to help us out," Mr. Shelly said. "I'm ready to go in the direction to keep the horses alive and give them to somebody else, but right now the best alternative is having some sort of slaughter facility to come and do it."

The horses, tens of thousands of them, are at the center of a passionate dispute playing out in court, in Congress and even within tribes across the West about whether federal authorities should sanction their slaughtering to thin the herds. The practice has never been banned, but it stopped when money for inspections was cut from the federal budget.

In Navajo territory, parched by years of unrelenting drought and beset by poverty, one feral horse consumes 20 liters of water and 8 kilograms of forage a day, some of which the Indians need for their cattle.

There are 75,000 feral and wild horses in the United States, Mr. Shelly said. They have no owners,

and many are believed to be native to the West. The tribes say they must find an efficient way of reducing the population. Although it is common to shoot old horses, there are too many of them to be dealt with, and there is money to be made rounding them up and selling them.

There is also the question of sovereignty, one of the points raised in a resolution endorsing horse slaughter that was issued by the National Congress of American Indians, the oldest and largest organization of American Indian and Alaska Native tribal governments.

Citing hillsides and valleys denuded by overgrazing by feral and wild horses, which on reservations throughout the West "are nearly everywhere you look," the resolution accuses the federal government of failing to consult the tribes before proposing language in the Agriculture Department's appropriations bill to again withhold money for slaughterhouse inspections.

Mr. Richardson acknowledged the conflict, which has sown divisions even among members of the same tribe. The plaintiffs in the lawsuit include tribesmen who spoke of American Indians' special relationship with horses, "the magnificent four-legged" animal "who has a part in our creation stories," as Paul Tohlakai, a Navajo, put it.

"Institutionally," Mr. Richardson said, "there have to be some issues that have to be dealt with, and that's why the ultimate solution is to find a natural habitat, or a series of natural habitats, and adoption for the horses."

The United States has never fostered a market for horse meat, a dietary staple in places like Belgium, China and Kazakhstan, but at one point, there were more than 10 slaughterhouses. The last three closed in 2007, after Congress banned the use of federal money for inspection of the facilities, which effectively ended the practice since they don't receive the government's seal of approval.

In their last year, the three plants slaughtered 30,000 horses for human consumption and shipped an additional 78,000 for slaughter in Canada and Mexico.

Wayne Pacelle, the president of the Humane Society of the United States, said the group's efforts were focused on preventing the killing of horses for human consumption "to avoid creating an industry that would turn horses into a global food commodity."

Mr. Pacelle said there were alternatives to slaughter, like using contraceptives to control the horse population.

For Mr. Shelly, his question has been whether it is better to slaughter free-roaming horses or, as many on the Navajo reservation have done, let them die slowly of thirst and disease.

The New York Times

(China Daily 09/01/2013 page9)

主站蜘蛛池模板: 狠狠色欧美亚洲综合色黑a| 国产人妖cd网站| 中文字幕成人免费视频| 永久免费AV无码网站YY| 国内国外精品影片无人区| 久久天天躁狠狠躁夜夜| 玉蒲团之天下第一| 国产免费牲交视频| 91av视频免费在线观看| 放荡的女老板bd中文字幕| 亚洲狠狠色丁香婷婷综合| 99这里只有精品| 日韩h片在线观看| 亚洲视频免费在线观看| 青青草综合在线| 国产美女在线一区二区三区| 亚洲情a成黄在线观看| 色一情一乱一伦一视频免费看| 成人欧美一区二区三区黑人| 亚洲欧美日韩中文字幕在线一 | 一个人看的www片免费中文| 日韩精品久久无码中文字幕 | 内射中出无码护士在线| 91香蕉视频成人| 国内精神品一区区| 亚洲gv天堂gv无码男同| 精品久久久久久无码人妻热| 女人张开腿让男人桶视频免费大全| 九一制片厂果冻传媒56| 波多野结衣种子网盘| 四只虎免费永久观看| 国产精品bbwbbwbbw| 日本三级生活片| 全彩福利本子h全彩在线观看 | 精彩视频一区二区三区| 大美香蕉伊在看欧美| 中文字幕在线观看亚洲| 日韩精品国产丝袜| 亚洲国产美女精品久久久久| 狠狠色综合网站久久久久久久 | 国产一区二区三区在线观看免费|